St. Petersburg, Florida’s beautiful coastline would definitely satisfy even the most avid angler. Out of many wonderful experiences you will have—each resulting in a catch—taking a fishing adventure for tarpon is one of those that leave you feeling the ultimate elation. Known for their strength and acrobatic shows, the tarpon, or the “silver kings,” will need the correct equipment and the right number of the best tarpon flies if you want to catch a big one.
Book Your Tarpon Fishing Now!
1. A Tarpon Toad
In 2024, the Tarpon Toad is still one of the tarpon flies preferred by most anglers out there, simply because of the consistency with which it continues to deliver results. Its very special design—with its fat head and long, flowing tail—gives this fly such action in the water that tarpon simply cannot help but find it irresistible. Its profile is very similar to that of small fish and shrimp, hence taking a place on the list as versatile and reliable.
So How and Why Does it Work Well?
- It has a chunky head and produces a very realistic swim.
- A long tail provides more visibility and action to fly.
- Works well in many different fishing conditions.
- Having the best colors: Chartreuse, Black/Purple, Olive/White
This movement which Tarpon Toad yields can, in the clear and shallow waters of St. Petersburg, draw tarpon from a distance hence making it one of the integral flies for your tackle box.
2. The Black Death
The Black Death fly is undoubtedly a mainstay in every tarpon angler’s box. Its uncomplicated yet effective design makes it the kind of fly tarpon anglers never leave home without, especially for clear water. It provides an unmistakable dark silhouette against a bright, tropical water backdrop, so tarpon can easily spot it.
How Does It Work?
- It is highly visible in almost any condition of water.
- Simple and very effective design
- Hundreds of tarpon caught with this fly
- Best Colors: Black/Red, Black/Purple
In the St. Petersburg area, the Black Death is quite visible in waters ranging from crystal clear to quite murky—the reliability for ever-consistent success.
3. EP Tarpon Streamer
Another leading contender for 2024 is Enrico Puglisi’s EP Tarpon Streamer. It offers the most realistic appearance due to its synthetic fiber makeup and ultimate durability, with an undulating action in the water imitating bait fish, which are a significant food source for tarpon.
How Does It Work in the Water?
- Realistic forage profile for baitfish.
- Durable synthetics for repeated use.
- Effective from two feet to 20+ feet.
- Best Colors: Chartreuse/White, Blue/White, Black/Purple
The EP Tarpon Streamer is a perfect choice for the varied fisheries taking place in the waters off St. Petersburg, from the sandy flats
4. Bunny Tarpon Flies
The Bunny Tarpon Fly is one of the most realistic and lively flies, created from rabbit strips; with that slight undulation it makes, it becomes almost irresistible to tarpon. Really deadly in murky waters where that extra movement helps attract fish.
How It Works:
- Natural movement due to rabbit strips
- Effective in various water conditions
- Simple but highly attractive design
- Best Colors: Black, White, Chartreuse
The Bunny Tarpon Fly, with its lifelike motion, is great in all of the varied water conditions around St. Petersburg.
5. Cockroach Fly
For decades, the Cockroach Fly has made its mark as a classic tarpon fly, still reigning supreme in 2024. Easy to tie with just a few feathers and fibers, the design brings you one of the simplest yet most effective flies available. The Cockroach Fly works wonders on crystal-clear and shallow waters where you would want more delicate presentations.
How Does it Work?
- Classic design with proven effectiveness.
- Easy to tie and modify.
- Great for clear water conditions.
- Best Colors: Brown/Orange, Black/Purple, Tan
For those flats and clear waters of St. Petersburg, the subtle yet effective presentation of the Cockroach Fly is just perfect for wary tarpon.
6. Tarpon Bunny
The Tarpon Bunny is another among rabbit-strip files that are worth having in any tarpon angler’s fly box. Pulsating action with a pleasingly realistic appearance makes this a pretty formidable trick for catching tarpon in quite a number of situations. These factors make it versatile and possessed of very lifelike action, hence its acceptance as the standard model among guides and hard-core anglers.
How Does It Work in the Water?
- Pulsating action from rabbit strips
- Versatile in different water conditions
- Highly attractive to tarpon
- Best Colors: Black, White/Red, Purple
This fly really works in the dynamic waters of St. Petersburg, loving changes and continuing to keep Tarpon interested.
Book Your Tarpon Fishing Now!7. Puglisi Peanut Butter
Another really fantastic fly to throw in your box for tarpon is from the arsenal of Enrico Puglisi: the Puglisi Peanut Butter. Full imitation of a lot of baitfish species is what this fly does, so it’s very versatile. Its synthetic fibers will make it tough, and the realistic profile will make it impossible to resist, even to the wariness of the wisest tarpon.
Why Does It Work Well?
- Realistic baitfish imitation.
- Durable and long-lasting material.
- It has proven both in skinny and deep water.
- Best Colors: Chartreuse/White, Blue/White, Olive/White
In the diverse and fertile fishing grounds of St. Petersburg, the flexibility and durability of the Puglisi Peanut Butter make it an indispensable tool.
Tips for Fishing Tarpon Flies St Petersburg
Match the Hatch: Observe the baitfish in your area and get a good Tarpon fly close in size and color to what they are eating.
Vary Your Retrieve: Try different speeds and patterns when retrieving the fly. Sometimes, it’s that slow, steady retrieve; other times, it may be a really fast, kind of erratic retrieve that will pop those fish off.
Strong Leaders: Tarpons are very powerful fish, so you will need a strong leader, preferably one that resists abrasions to avoid line breakage in the struggle.
Practice Your Casting: Wind makes casting even more of a challenge when it blows on the tarpon, so accuracy in your casting means everything. Get some practice into your casting so you can deliver that fly where it has to go.
Local Knowledge: Hook up with guides and other local fishermen for help on the best locations and methods, tips that are specific to St. Petersburg. Their advice could make all the difference in achieving success.
Always Remember!
Choosing the right fly is very important in catching tarpon, especially in a vast and lively environment like St. Petersburg, Florida. Some of the top tarpon flies in 2024 combine realistic profiles with enticing and highly resilient movements. Throw these flies into your arsenal with some other additional key tips, and you will be well-equipped to take on the thrill of tarpon fishing.
Ready to Catch the Big Silver King?
If you’re looking to make the most of your inshore fishing adventures and tarpon fishing in St. Peterburg Bay, don’t hesitate to reach out to us Copeland Outdoors. We have expert advice and local knowledge will help ensure that your fishing trips are successful and enjoyable. Contact now!
Book Your Tarpon Fishing Now!